Difference between file system and database system with an example

"They're the same"

Yes, storing data is just storing data. At the end of the day, you have files. You can store lots of stuff in lots of files & folders, there are situations where this will be the way. There is a well-known versioning solution (svn) that finally ended up using a filesystem-based model to store data, ditching their BerkeleyDB. Rare but happens. More info.

"They're quite different"

In a database, you have options you don't have with files. Imagine a textfile (something like tsv/csv) with 99999 rows. Now try to:

  • Insert a column. It's painful, you have to alter each row and read+write the whole file.
  • Find a row. You either scan the whole file or build an index yourself.
  • Delete a row. Find row, then read+write everything after it.
  • Reorder columns. Again, full read+write.
  • Sort rows. Full read, some kind of sort - then do it next time all over.

There are lots of other good points but these are the first mountains you're trying to climb when you think of a file based db alternative. Those guys programmed all this for you, it's yours to use; think of the likely (most frequent) scenarios, enumerate all possible actions you want to perform on your data, and decide which one works better for you. Think in benefits, not fashion.

Again, if you're storing JPG pictures and only ever look for them by one key (their id maybe?), a well-thought filesystem storage is better. Filesystems, btw, are close to databases today, as many of them use a balanced tree approach, so on a BTRFS you can just put all your pictures in one folder - and the OS will silently implement something like an early SQL query each time you access your files.

So, database or files?...
Let's see a few typical examples when one is better than the other. (These are no complete lists, surely you can stuff in a lot more on both sides.)

DB tables are much better when:

  • You want to store many rows with the exact same structure (no block waste)
  • You need lightning-fast lookup / sorting by more than one value (indexed tables)
  • You need atomic transactions (data safety)
  • Your users will read/write the same data all the time (better locking)

Filesystem is way better if:

  • You like to use version control on your data (a nightmare with dbs)
  • You have big chunks of data that grow frequently (typically, logfiles)
  • You want other apps to access your data without API (like text editors)
  • You want to store lots of binary content (pictures or mp3s)

TL;DR

Programming rarely says "never" or "always". Those who say "database always wins" or "files always win" probably just don't know enough. Think of the possible actions (now + future), consider both ways, and choose the fastest / most efficient for the case. That's it.



Difference Between File System and DBMS

The main difference between file system and DBMS is that the file system helps to store a collection of raw data files into the hard disk while the DBMS helps to easily store, retrieve and manipulate data in a database.

A file system is a software that manages the data files in a computer system. On the other hand, DBMS is a software to create and manage databases. Handling a file system is easier than DBMS, but the DBMS provides more advantages than a file system.

Difference between file system and database system with an example

Difference Between File System and DBMS

DBMSFile System
DBMS is a collection of data. In DBMS, the user is not required to write the procedures. File system is a collection of data. In this system, the user has to write the procedures for managing the database.
DBMS gives an abstract view of data that hides the details. File system provides the detail of the data representation and storage of data.
DBMS provides a crash recovery mechanism, i.e., DBMS protects the user from the system failure. File system doesn't have a crash mechanism, i.e., if the system crashes while entering some data, then the content of the file will lost.
DBMS provides a good protection mechanism. It is very difficult to protect a file under the file system.
DBMS contains a wide variety of sophisticated techniques to store and retrieve the data. File system can't efficiently store and retrieve the data.
DBMS takes care of Concurrent access of data using some form of locking. In the File system, concurrent access has many problems like redirecting the file while other deleting some information or updating some information.
Redundancy is control in DBMS Redundancy not control in file system
Unauthorized access is restricted in DBMS Not in the file system
DBMS provide back up and recovery Data lost in file system can't be recovered.
DBMS provide multiple user interfaces Data is isolated in file system.
A database management system coordinates both the physical and the logical access to the data file-processing system coordinates only the physical access.
A database management system is designed to allow flexible access to data (i.e. queries) A file-processing system is designed to allow predetermined access to data (i.e. compiled programs).
A database management system is designed to coordinate multiple users accessing the same data at the same time. A file-processing system is usually designed to allow one or more programs to access different data files at the same time.


Buy This Ad Space @$20 per Month, Ad Size 600X200 Contact on: or 9999595223

Difference between file system and database system with an example

What is the difference between file systems and database systems?

File System Vs DBMS: Explore What is the Difference between File System and DBMS. File System helps to store a collection of raw files of data into a hard disk, while DBMS is a software system, and it helps to store, manipulate or recover data.

What is an example of a file system?

Examples include FAT (FAT12, FAT16, FAT32), exFAT, NTFS, HFS and HFS+, HPFS, APFS, UFS, ext2, ext3, ext4, XFS, btrfs, Files-11, Veritas File System, VMFS, ZFS, ReiserFS and ScoutFS. Some disk file systems are journaling file systems or versioning file systems.

What is the difference between a database and a file give examples of each?

A File System is a collection of raw data files stored in the hard-drive, whereas a database is intended for easily organizing, storing and retrieving large amounts of data. In other words, a database holds a bundle of organized data typically in a digital form for one or more users.

What is file in DBMS with example?

A file is a sequence of records stored in binary format. A disk drive is formatted into several blocks that can store records. File records are mapped onto those disk blocks.